Question

Consider the following relation on subsets of the set SS of integers between 1 and 2014. For two distinct subsets UU and VV of SS we say U<VU < V if the minimum element in the symmetric difference of the two sets is in UU.

Consider the following two statements:

S1S1: There is a subset of SS that is larger than every other subset.

S2S2: There is a subset of SS that is smaller than every other subset.

Which one of the following is CORRECT?

Choose one option
Official answer and solution
Official answer
A
From
Official GATE 2014 answer key

Solution

Analyze the ordering relation on the finite power set P(S) to identify the unique maximal and minimal subsets.

  1. Relation Definition:
    For distinct subsets U,V⊆SU, V \subseteq S:

    U<V  ⟺  min⁡(UΔV)∈U.U < V \iff \min(U \Delta V) \in U.

    Note that if m=min⁡(UΔV)∈Um = \min(U \Delta V) \in U, then m∉Vm \notin V. This defines a strict total linear order (anti-lexicographic order) on the power set P(S)\mathcal{P}(S).

  2. Candidate for Smallest Subset (S2):

    • Consider the set SS itself (the entire set).
    • For any other subset V⊊SV \subsetneq S, SΔV=S∖VS \Delta V = S \setminus V.
    • Since S∖V⊆SS \setminus V \subseteq S, the minimum element of SΔVS \Delta V is an element of SS, which means min⁡(SΔV)∈S\min(S \Delta V) \in S.
    • Therefore, by definition, S<VS < V holds for every subset V≠SV \ne S.
    • Thus, SS is smaller than every other subset of SS. Statement S2S2 is TRUE.
  3. Candidate for Largest Subset (S1):

    • Consider the empty set ∅\emptyset.
    • For any non-empty subset U⊆SU \subseteq S, UΔ∅=UU \Delta \emptyset = U.
    • The minimum element of UU is obviously an element of UU, so min⁡(UΔ∅)∈U\min(U \Delta \emptyset) \in U.
    • By definition, U<∅U < \emptyset holds for every non-empty subset UU.
    • This means that every other subset is smaller than ∅\emptyset, which equivalently means that ∅\emptyset is larger than every other subset! Statement S1S1 is TRUE.
  4. Conclusion:
    Both S1 and S2 are true, corresponding to option (A).

Final answer

A

Common trap

Intuitively expecting emptyset to be the smallest and S to be the largest; the definition puts the subset containing the minimum differing element as the smaller one, reversing the usual subset inclusion intuition.

The answer is the one in the official GATE answer key. The solution is this site's own explanation.

Source

Paper
GATE 2014 Computer Science and Information Technology (CS) Session 2
Question
60 of 65, printed as CS Q.50
Section
Computer Science and Information Technology

Report an error in this question

GATE questions are the work of the organising institutes. This site is independent and is not affiliated with them.